Bringing science to bear, at last, on the gun control debate. Provides a discussion that is deeply philosophical moral and political philosophy yet accessible. There is no evidence that existing gun control laws have reduced crime and violence. The left will never win the guncontrol debate, because its too hard to persuade people to give up their right to selfdefense. Prohibition and the 1929 st valentines day massacre, in particular, led to the first serious attempt by congress to regulate firearms. The term gun control as it is used in the united states refers to any action taken by the federal government or by state or local governments to regulate, through legislation, the sale, purchase, safety, and use of handguns and other types of firearms by individual citizens. Advocacy for guncontrol laws may never provide the same singleminded identity that politicized gun ownership seems to exert. The gun control debate in the united states goes back to the nations founding, when the framers of the constitution first wrote the second amendment, allowing private citizens to keep and bear arms. The history of the us gun control debate explained historyextra. Colleagues of mine have done an excellent job responding to the arguments about whether or not gun control would.
To provide a brief glimpse into the wide spectrum of opinions on this topic, the symposiums guest editors have invited two prominent and opposing voices on this subject. But the 2008 edition of gun digest buyers guide to assault weapons, a book for gun enthusiasts, lays out a pretty specific definition. Guncontrol supporters are often disadvantaged in the debate because. But this year, again thanks in part to the parkland students, its. Why almost everything youve heard about gun control is wrong is a book by john lott, following up on his controversial more guns, less crime.
Legislation pushing for increased gun control, including more expansive background checks, is slated to go to the senate this fall. Faced with a generation of defeat in the gun debate, the left is increasingly turning to one of its favorite weapons in the culture war, stigma. These volumes analyze documents that have played a significant role in the attempt to balance the long tradition of gun culture in this country with calls for gun control, including. This means that the laws preventing serial killers and rapists from legally obtaining a firearm is a form of gun control. By the end of the book you have a foundational sense of the basic arguments on each side. Mar 24, 2018 these debates often pit gun control activists against the national rifle association nra, which claims to speak on behalf of gun owners. Semiautomatic rifles that accept detachable magazines holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition, and often include. Gun control in america is really a big debate and this book has tackled this topic perfectly. The core essays of this book were collected by asking gun rights groups and progun control groups to recommend the strongest pieces advocating their position. The volume includes information on gun control pertaining to u. The debates surrounding gun control are noisy perhaps.
What is the central issue in the gun control debate. Since the gun control debate reemerged in the national discourse, nra spokesman andrew arulanadam said the group has added 250,000 new members it reached 4. A debate on gun control was held between second amendment expert david kopel and gun control advocate arnie grossman. The term gun control as it is used in the united states refers to any action taken by the federal government or by state or local governments to regulate, through legislation, the sale, purchase, safety, and use of handguns and other types of firearms by individual citizens the political and social debate over the question of how much gun control is. Aug 05, 2019 the gun rights versus gun control debate in the us touches on a wide range of cultural and political issues that go much deeper than the question of access to firearms. Jan 09, 2018 9 books about gun control to read if you want to argue in favor of stricter laws. Indeed, even as thousands rally for new legislation, opponents contend that such measures wont prevent determined criminals from obtaining a firearm and that responsible gun ownership makes communities safer. This article is based on debates between people in favor of gun control and the opposition.
It is intended to reach a broader audience than its highly technical predecessor. In this mythbusting book on gun violence, director of the harvard injury control research center and the harvard youth violence prevention center david. Minimizing the use of guns may not diminish the crimes because it is on the hands of the user that matters. British wanker piers morgan hell bent on pushing antigun propaganda to disarm the american people ahead of an economic collapse gets angry after losing gun control debate and crumples up. Still, the book is an important read even for gun control advocates. At the time the first edition of this book was published in 1990 there is an expanded 2nd edition availble. The opponents on gun control comment on how guns cannot only be for recreational use like hunting and target shooting but also for defending themselves and their property. A key question for the book, then, concerns how it will play into its own analysis, where a tightly controlled interest group politics, cementing the. The debates surrounding gun control are noisy perhaps theyre designed to be, in hopes that if we can just get one another yelling loud enough, it will create the illusion that something is.
Semiautomatic rifles that accept detachable magazines holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition, and often include features such as a pistol grip, flash suppressor, folding stock or bayonet mount and. For the first time this book compiles a comprehensive array of documents that explain and illuminate the historical and contemporary context of the modern gun debate. Gun control is one of the most enduringly controversial issues in modern american politics. Featuring selections from historians, criminologists, social scientists, public health specialists, and jurists, dr nisbet offers an indepth analysis of the central questions. Its a purely political agenda that has been spun as crime prevention, keeping our streets safe, or my personal favorite, protecting our children. Lax gun control laws are economically costly the coalition for gun control claims that, in canada, the costs of firearms death and injury including murder, suicide and unintentional injuries alone have been estimated at 6 billion dollars per year. The issue of gun control in the united states generates heated and passionate debate whenever it comes up. Research related to this issue strongly supports the claim that there should be more gun control laws. The guncontrol debate, explained in 5 questions the. Yet the responses to both essays have helped demonstrate why the left keeps losing on guns. At the end of the twentieth century and into the twentyfirst, highly publicised gun massacres, especially in schools, have maintained gun control as a hotly contested, peculiarly american, political and cultural debate. The united states leads all nations in rates of private gun ownership, yet stories of gun tragedies frequent the news, spurring calls for tighter gun regulations.
Gun control was the leading term on cable news 656 programs out of 1,425 and no. The popular view of the american revolution holds that the colonists fought the british for liberty and freedom, and against tyranny. Does there need to be stricter laws for gun control. Anger and grief in the wake of the shootings at sandy hook elementary school are palpable in this urgent piece of writing, but no less remarkable are kings keen thoughtfulness and composure as he explores the contours of the guncontrol issue and constructs. The gun control debate spikes in attention and shifts in public opinion. But in reality, the nra represents the interest of gun.
Center survey marked the first time in two decades that more americans supported the concept of gun rights than gun control. He follows with both a consequentialist case and a rightsbased case for moderately extensive gun control, before discussing gun politics and advancing policy suggestions. King is a gun owner who sees that guns are not as important as people, and he puts forward his case with passion, conviction and clarity. If arguments for gun control dont grapple with this reality, then theyre destined to fail. Newtown ranked second on cable 605 shows and first on broadcast at 259. In this mythbusting book on gun violence, director of the harvard injury control research. This book has a great sense of righteousness and equality in every statement it gives. These books will make you think differently about the gun. The gun control debate has become one of the most intense arguments in the history of the second amendment and will continue to be a discussion amongst individuals. Prometheus books, 1990 firearms ownership 341 pages. Columbine and other highly publicized shootings have kept ame.
In most cases, debates about gun control in the us have followed periods of violence. Dec 03, 2015 but progunrights economist john lott jr. The district had some of the strictest gun control laws in the us, barring individuals from keeping a gun in the home. Its mobilizing its tribe including progressive corporations, hollywood, and the mainstream media to not just make policy arguments. Gun control in the united states is rooted in the federal constitution under the 2 nd amendment.
What to read if you want to understand the politics of guns in america. The central question is the extent to which federal or state governments should regulate gun. The most common guncontrol arguments of today go something like this. Americans own an estimated 300 million guns, and the debate surrounding that ownership has long been a charged one. Gun ownership protection by the second amendment to the us constitution is usually the main argument against gun control. The oregon community college where nine recently died wasnt a gunfree zone. Umpqua community college allowed anyone with a concealandcarry permit to bring their guns inside. The battle over the right to bear arms in america by adam winkler. Lax gun control laws and the diffusion of weapons in a society, better enable a country to defend itself. Sep 25, 20 the issue of gun control in the united states generates heated and passionate debate whenever it comes up. A government may be justified in adopting lax gun control laws as a means to national defense. The debate tends to be acrimonious and is frequently misinformed and illogical.
These shootings would stop if we banned ar15s or other semiauto rifles. Aug 05, 2019 media caption why the nra wields so much power. During a cnn town hall on gun control, a furious crowd of americans jeered at two conservatives, marco rubio and dana loesch, who stood in defense of. Gun control laws and lower gun ownership rates do not prevent suicides. Debates have risen between citizens on how the government should establish stronger gun control laws. Thats why possibly the hardest debates on gun control take place in the usa. The history of the us gun control debate explained.
The writer of this book, which provides an analysis of the gun control debate, came to the issue with fresh eyes or, as he writes, with no gun in. From a gun culture that took root early in american history to the mass shootings that repeatedly bring the public discussion of gun control to a fever pitch, the topic has preoccupied citizens, public officials, and special interest groups for decades. Facts on background checks, concealedcarry laws, u. Its not a perfect book, it probably isnt about to change the world, but if just a few people will read it and be made to think, then i think it will have done its job. But gun debates in the united states have proven to be contentious and intractable. Lotts assumptions are worth examining, particularly his concept of an acceptable level of deaths. Americans have a deeply ambivalent relationship to guns. Debating gun control how much regulation do we need. It also serves to stop gun shops from selling to said serial killers and rapists.
In debating this important topic, the authors elevate the quality of discussion from the levels that usually prevail in the public arena. In particular, it may allow for a country to mobilize forces in self defense. A short reading list to make your gun debate smarter. View the latest news on the gun control debate and the business of guns in america. There has been a series of heated debates on gun control following the aftermath of the sandy hook shooting on december 14, 2012 in newtown, connecticut. Gun control became a much bigger topic shortly after the november 22. The reason why this has attracted so much attention is because not everyone is in favor of gun control and each side brings up excellent points about the issue.
Mark jurkowitz, associate director, pew research centers project for excellence in journalism 202 4193650 1615 l st, n. Still there are a couple countries with permissive gun control regimes. The nra today is a powerful pro gun lobbying group that fiercely resists gun control efforts and says it has five million members. Despite the national rifle association strong objections against these issues, gun control laws must be increased. You decide contemporary issues, lee nisbet was professor of philosophy at medaille college in buffalo, new york. Gun control would destroy this timehonored tradition.
Lithuania has one of the worlds lowest gun ownership rates 0. Mar 05, 2018 since the late 1990s, the centers for disease control and prevention has been wary of studying gun issues after nra lobbyists convinced congress to cut into its funding after a series of studies. A quinnipiac university poll in june 2017 showed 94% of voters support background checks for. These debates often pit gun control activists against the national rifle association nra, which claims to speak on behalf of gun owners. Argument in favor of gun control essay 805 words cram. The guncontrol debate after parkland the new yorker. Although they tend to favor stricter regulation, their book is balanced. Jan 23, 2020 the gun control debate in the united states goes back to the nations founding, when the framers of the constitution first wrote the second amendment, allowing private citizens to keep and bear arms. But not all gun owners are against all forms of gun control. These are emotionbased arguments and will do nothing to solve the problem. Toronto shooting reignites canadas guncontrol debate. These books will make you think differently about the gun control. In essence, the 2 nd amendment was created so that the people would have arms to overthrow a tyrannical government.
You decide contemporary issues in philosophy lee nisbet on. Gun control debates create gun production booms, government. Federally, this interpretation has been upheld, most recently in 2010. In a pullsnopunches essay intended to provoke rational discussion, stephen king sets down his thoughts about gun violence in america. Due to its colonial history and gun culture, usa is one of them. Oct 08, 2015 still, the book is an important read even for gun control advocates. It doesnt go so far as to call for a total ban, though. No topic is more polarizing than guns and gun control. Many other related acts of gun violence have brought up issues on gun control.
1241 1069 288 1288 959 887 1378 1090 1503 723 955 310 1577 1542 10 196 1487 1046 521 937 312 1431 1014 1527 752 335 1141 773 1374 1414 1295 1344 1149 1523 810 1024 1155 943 1221 1074 1475 317 1098 1311 1282 1026